How to write small group discussion questions that open people up

Some book titles on this page link to Books-A-Million. If you buy through one of those links, The Lamplit Team may earn a commission. It does not change what we recommend.
Most hosts know the evening I mean. You have read the chapter twice, you have a list of questions, and the first one lands with a soft thud. "Did everyone like this week's reading?" Nods. A "yes, it was good." Someone reaches for a cookie. You move to the next question and it goes the same way, and by half past eight you are doing most of the talking.
It is rarely the people. Small group discussion questions fail for ordinary, fixable reasons: they can be answered in one word, they test whether people did the reading, or they ask for something so personal that nobody wants to go first. Change the question and the same room often opens up.
What follows is how I write questions now, for a book club, a Bible study, a parents' group or a neighborhood group reading something together. It takes about twenty minutes a week once you have the pattern.
What a good question does
A good question gives people somewhere to start and room to keep going. It has more than one honest answer. It asks about what people noticed or experienced, not what they know. And it is short enough that someone can hold it in their head while they think.
A useful test: could a person who only skimmed the reading still answer it? If yes, you have probably asked about experience and attention, which is where most good conversation lives. If only the person who took notes can answer, you have written a quiz.
Four kinds of question in one evening
I build every evening from four kinds of question, in this order. You do not need many of each. Five or six questions in total is plenty for ninety minutes, and most weeks I do not reach the last one.
The way in
An easy, low-stakes question that everyone can answer in a sentence. It gets every voice into the room early. It can be linked to the reading ("Which character would you most like to have dinner with?") or not linked at all. If you want more of these, I keep a longer list of small group icebreakers that nobody dreads.
Noticing
Questions about what is actually on the page. "What stood out to you?" is the classic, and it works, but it gets tired if you use it every week. Try "Which line did you underline?", "Where did you slow down?" or "What surprised you?" These are safe because the answer is about the text, not about the person.
Wondering
Questions that ask people to think a little further. Why did she make that choice? What would have happened if he had stayed? What do you think the writer wanted us to feel at the end of the chapter? This is where people start disagreeing, gently, and where the evening gets interesting.
Bringing it home
One question that turns toward ordinary life. "Where have you seen something like this?" or "Is there anything here you would like to try this week?" Keep it optional in tone. Some people will answer with something real, and some will answer with something small, and both are fine.
Weak questions and better ones
Most weak questions can be rescued with a small change of wording. Here are the patterns I see most often, with a fix for each.
| Weak version | What goes wrong | Better version |
|---|---|---|
| Did you like the chapter? | Yes or no, then silence | What part of the chapter stayed with you? |
| What are the three reasons the author gives? | A quiz with a right answer | Which of the author's reasons convinced you most, and which least? |
| Why was the brother wrong to leave? | The answer is built into the question | What do you make of the brother's decision to leave? |
| How has this changed your life? | Far too big, nobody goes first | Is there one small thing here you might try this week? |
| Does anyone have any thoughts? | Too vague to grab | Where did you find yourself agreeing, or arguing back? |
| Don't you think forgiveness is hard? | Leads people to your view | When have you seen someone forgive well? |
Notice that the better versions are often no longer than the weak ones. The difference is that they invite a range of answers and make it safe to give a small one.
A question sheet you can copy
I write my questions on one index card or one note on my phone, using the same layout every week. Here it is with an example filled in for a book club chapter. Copy the blank lines and use them for anything: a novel, a study guide, a short passage, an article.
QUESTION SHEET
Week: 4 of 8
Reading: Chapter 6
WAY IN (everyone, one sentence)
Which character would you most like to sit next to on a long train ride?
NOTICING (pick one or two)
Which line or moment did you mark, or think about afterwards?
Where did the chapter slow down for you?
WONDERING (one or two)
What do you make of Ruth's choice not to tell her sister?
If the chapter ended a page earlier, how would it feel different?
BRINGING IT HOME (one, optional in tone)
Where have you seen a secret like that help, or hurt?
IF WE RUN SHORT
What do you hope happens next?
CLOSING (always)
What will you take away from tonight?
The "if we run short" line is a safety net. Most weeks you will not need it. On the weeks you do, it saves you from staring at the floor.
Writing your questions in twenty minutes
Here is the routine I use, usually on the evening before the group meets.
- Read the material once through without making notes.
- Read it again with a pencil. Mark anything that surprised you, puzzled you or made you stop.
- Turn three of those marks into questions. Start each one with "what", "where", "which" or "how". Avoid "did", "is" and "don't you think", which tend to produce yes or no.
- Write one way-in question and one bringing-it-home question.
- Read every question aloud. If you run out of breath, it is too long. If you can predict the answer, rewrite it.
- Cross out anything that only you would find interesting. It happens to every host.
If your group uses a study guide with printed questions, you can still use this routine. Pick the two or three printed questions that suit your group best and rewrite them in plain words. Guides are written for every group at once. You are writing for the eight people who will be on your sofa.
Asking them in the room
A good question can still fall flat if it is asked badly. Three habits help more than anything else.
Ask once, then wait. Say the question, then stop. Count to ten in your head. The silence feels long, but people are thinking, and if you jump in to explain or rephrase, you teach them that you will always fill the gap. If nobody speaks after a real pause, ask a simpler version, not a longer one.
Follow up with something short. When someone gives an answer, the best next question is often tiny: "Say more?", "What made you notice that?" or simply "And what else?" That last one comes from The Coaching Habit, where Michael Bungay Stanier makes the case for asking short questions and then staying curious a little longer than feels natural. It works just as well on a sofa as in an office.
Let the group answer each other. When someone makes a point, resist responding to it yourself. Look around and ask, "Does anyone see it differently?" The conversation should move across the circle, not back and forth between you and each person in turn.
Questions to retire
Some questions turn up in almost every group and almost never work. I have stopped using these.
"Any final thoughts?" at the end of the evening produces a tired silence. A specific closing question ("What will you take away from tonight?") does the job better.
"What does this mean to you?" is so wide that people do not know where to begin. Narrow it to a line, a moment or a choice.
Questions that ask people to admit a failing in front of the group, such as "Where have you been selfish this week?", put everyone on guard. If a question would feel awkward to answer at a dinner party, it is probably too much for a weekly group, unless the group has met for a long time and chosen that kind of honesty together.
And any question you are asking mainly to steer people toward your own conclusion. People can tell. You are there to open the conversation, not to win it.
If you are new to hosting, the questions are only one part of the evening. There is a fuller plan for the first night in how to lead a small group when you have never led one, and more on hosting across the small groups section. For next week, take the blank sheet above, fill in one question for each heading, and read them aloud in your kitchen before anyone arrives. You will hear straight away which one needs rewriting.



